The McKinsey Quarterly

  • Recommend (80)
  • Text Size
  • Print
  • Download PDF
  • Link to This

When job seekers invade Facebook

The increasing popularity of online social networking is changing not only the way people manage their careers but social networking itself.

This short essay is a Conversation Starter, one in a series of invited opinions on topical issues. Read what the authors have to say, then let us know what you think.

As the downturn continues, millions of corporate managers—gripped by the job jitters—are rushing to join online social networks in a scramble to build their social capital. The popularity of sites such as LinkedIn is soaring: less than a year ago the site had little brand profile and was seen mostly as a venue for corporate suits trolling for professional contacts while plotting their next career move. Facebook, by contrast, has largely attracted individuals seeking a compelling site for fun social networking.

Today LinkedIn’s year-on-year growth is up nearly 200 percent in the United States and it now has more than 35 million members—many of whom were formerly employed within the hard-hit financial sector. And it’s just one of the many sites to which recession-struck managers are flocking: Xing (based in Germany), with its 7 million members and special Lehman Brothers alumni section, and Meet the Boss (based in the United Kingdom), which restricts membership to C-level financial types, are also experiencing burgeoning membership levels.

This surging popularity of online social networking is transforming the nature of business networking, with profound implications for the way business people manage their careers. But it also augurs profound change for social networking itself.

With so many people stampeding into Web-based social networks, the line between social and business networking is becoming increasingly blurred. An important question is whether the values and codes of conduct specific to the virtual world will come into conflict with real-world values and norms. Facebook, where the idea of a “friend” is directly embedded in the interface, is increasingly cluttered with self-promoters, career artists, and marketing entrepreneurs. What happens as this trend intensifies and those using Facebook exclusively for career networking invade?

There are, of course, powerful economic reasons behind the trend. As sociologist Nan Lin puts it in his book, Social Capital,1 “Individuals engage in interactions and networking in order to produce profits.” These profits are based upon information, influence, social credentials, and recognition. The accumulated social capital, meanwhile, helps individuals to gain competitive advantages in the labor market as a result of privileged access to “resources” located on the social networks.

Still, for many there’s nothing more irritating than when a new “friend” contacts you almost immediately with an inappropriate request for a favor. Generally, it’s more advisable to approach social networking as a giver, not a taker, and gradually build relationships according to reciprocated favors. Overall, online social networking, with its support groups and trusted access, is governed by a culture of sharing, not selling.

And can the throngs of interlopers really be considered friends? Anthropologists tell us that it’s impossible to maintain stable social relationships with more than 150 people. Maintaining a professional network of more than 150 looser connections on LinkedIn might be plausible, but it would strain the richer social relations that make up the fabric of sites such as Facebook. Among Facebook’s 175 million members, the instances of “defriending” are already growing.

It’s a safe bet that if the economic downturn grinds on, we will witness further conflict between the nonrational instinct to connect socially and the rational calculation to build social capital for professional reasons. If so, it may put further strain on the notion of an online friend. We may find ourselves asking more frequently that age-old question, “What are friends for?” Q logo

We invite you to add your thoughts to the conversation.

About the Authors

Professor Soumitra Dutta is the Roland Berger Chaired Professor of Business and Technology at INSEAD, where Dr. Matthew Fraser is a senior research fellow. Their book, Throwing Sheep in the Boardroom: How Online Social Networking Will Change Your Life, Work and World, was published by Wiley in December 2008.

Notes

1Nan Lin, Social Capital: A Theory of Social Structure and Action, New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, 2001.

Recommend (80)
  • 20 MARCH 2010
    Mohit Handa
    Deputy Manager
    HCL
    Noida India

    ...Over the past few years, social networking sites have spawned to capture market share but they will soon enter into a phase of consolidation at global level...

    .
    Mohit Handa
    Deputy Manager
    HCL
    Noida India

    The growing popularity of social networking for professional reasons could be due to multiple reasons. From a head hunter’s perspective, it certainly crashes the cost and time to hire. Employers get a fair bit of idea of the potential employee before getting face-to-face. It’s not just what the candidate claims, there are many indicators available to judge the fitment - friend list, comments, testimonials, communities- all these can be used to gauge the candidate.

    We also need to look at this development in isolation from the economic downturn. Over the past few years, social networking sites have spawned to capture market share but they will soon enter into a phase of consolidation at global level while other regional and niche sites will continue to cater to specific audiences. Since customers and eyeballs are the most treasured assets of these social networking sites, there will be increased M&A activity in this space. That naturally will bring in a lot more regulation and scrutiny into these freewheeling forums.

    What is not to be missed in this new age business is the role of fast developing economies like China, India, Vietnam, Brazil et al. The numbers and the eyeballs will come from these geographies and the providers of platforms will have to cater to the needs of these economies.

    Another reason for use of online social networking by job seekers is because they understand the need to make themselves available to as many “job consultants” as possible. Job consultants will continue playing pivotal role with the help of information available on the social networking sites. This link of job consultants between job seekers and providers is not going away anywhere in near future, although they will have to adapt to provide more value-add with most of the basic information available freely on LinkedIn’s and Facebook’s of the world.

    .
  • 11 MARCH 2009

    Our readers are passionate about their online networks—both social and professional.

    Click here to read a selection of letters on “When job seekers invade Facebook.”

    .

    Our readers are passionate about their online networks—both social and professional.

    Click here to read a selection of letters on “When job seekers invade Facebook.”

    .
Submit Your Comments

The user information you enter into this form will not update your site profile. To update your profile, please visit your profile page.

Subject When job seekers invade Facebook

*Required

We may publish your comments online and in the print edition of McKinsey Quarterly. Those chosen, which may be edited for length and clarity, will appear along with your name and details, but not your e-mail address. We will use your e-mail address only to send you a confirmation copy of your comments and to notify you if we publish them online.

We value your feedback and will consider it carefully. Nonetheless, we receive so many comments that we cannot acknowledge all of them.

See also:
Preview

Keep In Touch with McKinsey Quarterly: RSS, Facebook, Twitter, widgets, audio and video podcasts, purchase McKinsey Quarterly in print on Amazon and download the digital edition from Zinio Sign up for a personalized RSS feed Become a fan on Facebook Follow @McKQuarterly on Twitter Add Quarterly headlines to your Web site Watch Quarterly video podcasts Listen to Quarterly audio podcasts Purchase McKinsey Quarterly print issues Purchase McKinsey Quarterly print issues
Embed E-mail