The McKinsey Quarterly

  • Recommend (99)
  • Text Size
  • Print
  • Download PDF
  • Link to This

Revealing your moment of truth

Management thinker Stan Slap argues that the best leaders inspire their teams by bringing their values to work.

The purpose of leadership isn’t to increase shareholder value or the productivity of work teams, though effective leadership does these things. Rather, the purpose of leadership is to change the world around you in the name of your values, so you can live those values more fully and use them to make life better for others. The process of leadership is to turn your values into a compelling cause for others.

After all, you can’t live your top personal values at work without the support of your people. But could they, without hesitation, pick your values from a long list? Could they describe the benefits of supporting those values? If the answer to either question is no—and for most senior managers it is—then you haven’t begun to see the performance your people are capable of.

To change this dynamic, you must reset the standard of what’s possible in the relationship between you and your people. In my experience, the best method for accomplishing this objective is to reveal “moments of truth”: the stories of how you know your values are real to you, where they came from and how you learned them, and the intimate and profound personal experiences—glorious or traumatic—that shaped your self-awareness.

To pull this feat off, you’ll have to step out from behind whatever protection your job title affords and make yourself willingly vulnerable. In doing so, you are saying: “From my experiences, this is what is most important about living.” By disclosing how your unshakable view of life priorities was formed, you are offering proof of your commitment to these values. One well-known senior executive took this advice to heart and told her staff about a savage yet triumphant experience that she had never previously revealed to most of her friends—and certainly never to her employees—in a way that underlined just how strongly she felt about her connection to them. This is her story.

One executive’s moment of truth

“I grew up in a very small town in the Deep South. There were two schools in our town: the white school and the black school. Since I’m black, I went to the black school, which didn’t have as many teachers or books or fun things as the white school. But I was a smart little girl, and my mother made up for the lack of resources when I got home every day. Before I could go out and play, we would sit at the dining-room table, and she would take down a big, old encyclopedia from the shelf and teach me about the world.

“I looked up to see four huge men on horseback with masks on, carrying baseball bats. They were riding right at us.”

“One day I brought home a report card that was so good my mother said, ‘I think we can get you into the white school. Do you want to go?’ ‘Yes!’ I said, because I was a smart girl and I wanted to learn. I didn’t know that the school district was under a lot of federal pressure to integrate. Our family talked about it and decided that if the school would accept me, I would go—as long as my two older brothers transferred with me. My brothers didn’t want to go, but they loved their little sister and so they agreed. We would be the first black children at the school.

“I had only two dresses and I got to wear my church dress on my first day in school! I was assigned a seat in the back next to a little redheaded white girl and I immediately became best friends with her, the way little girls do. When the bell rang for recess, I went out to the schoolyard to play with my new friend and her other friends. All of the girls were on the schoolyard, and all of the boys were playing on the football field. A large wire fence separated the two areas. My new friend told me that boys and girls used to play together, but since my two brothers were here now the school had put up the fence to separate the boys from the girls.

“We were playing and screaming and laughing when we heard screaming of a different kind from the edge of the schoolyard. I looked up to see four huge men on horseback with masks on, carrying baseball bats. They were riding right at us. Everyone ran toward the school building. The teachers got there first and locked the doors behind them. As I was running, I could hear my brothers yelling my name. They were clawing at the fence, trying to save me, but the fence was too high.

“I was a fast little girl—weighed almost nothing, and most of it was legs. I was already almost to the bleacher seats stacked against the wall of the school building. I knew if I could scramble under those bleachers, the horses couldn’t get to me. I was just about to roll under the seats when I heard a scream I thought I recognized. I turned around and saw that one of the riders had grabbed my new friend by the hair—she had been playing with me—and was holding her a couple of feet off the ground. She was screaming and sobbing.

“I didn’t even stop to think. I just turned around and ran at that man on the horse. He was holding my friend on the left side of the horse. This horse was so big and it was sweating and its eyes were wild and glaring at me. It was trying to move around to kick me. I ran to the man’s right side and sunk my teeth into his leg, biting him as hard as I could.

“The good news is that he dropped my friend, but he picked me up instead. He dragged me by my arm across the concrete and two blocks outside the schoolyard. My Sunday dress got torn off. I was bruised all over, the skin on my back and side and left leg was in ribbons, and they told me that I lost a lot of blood. He left me lying in the street, but I don’t really remember that.

“My mother came to the hospital every day for five weeks. Every day, she brought my school lessons and that old encyclopedia and she would help me study the best I could. When I got out, she asked me what I wanted to do. ‘I want to go back to the white school and graduate,’ I said. And I did.

“I am a grown woman now. I am a successful executive. I am a wife and I am a mother. In this life, I have had an opportunity to learn what is most important to me, and what is most important to me is loyalty. The little white girl from that school is still my best friend today. I’m not willing to live without loyalty in my life and I’m not willing to have people I care about live without it.

“We have a lot of pressures on our team these days. You’re working very hard, and we often don’t get the cooperation we need from other departments. Things aren’t always easy for us, and I know that. I know this will change, because we will be the ones to change it. I just can’t tell you when it will change.

“But I can tell you this: if you are working for me and you ever get into trouble trying to do the right thing—I’m coming back for you.”

Postscript

As I’ve observed time and again in working with companies around the world, taking the risk to share a “moment of truth” can help make leaders better and produce real business benefits. But what if your story isn’t as jaw-dropping as this one?

The answer is that your story doesn’t have to be dramatic, only real. True epiphanies often come from a series of small moments—visible, for instance, only after reflecting on the decisions that first caused you to need your values or become aware of them. Indeed, simply looking at your values consciously often helps connect them to the specific moments—big or small—that made a difference to you then and can again now.

About the Author

Stan Slap is the author of Bury My Heart at Conference Room B: The Unbeatable Impact of Truly Committed Managers (Portfolio, 2010), from which this article was adapted.

Recommend (99)
  • 29 NOVEMBER 2010
    David Whelbourn
    Director of Project Management
    NBISA
    Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada

    ...inactions cast a long shadow into the future. They truly demonstrate your values and establish your reputation.

    .
    David Whelbourn
    Director of Project Management
    NBISA
    Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada

    Yes, be human to your team and use your experiences to present your values. However I believe Maksym is absolutely right, actions speak louder than words.

    Remember the logic of your actions, and inactions cast a long shadow into the future. They truly demonstrate your values and establish your reputation.

    .
  • 15 OCTOBER 2010
    Debbe Vo
    National Account Executive
    Quest
    Melbourne, Australia

    ...We all can learn from being loyal.

    .
    Debbe Vo
    National Account Executive
    Quest
    Melbourne, Australia

    I hope all senior management members out there remember where they came from as well. Connection to people and how they feel is a powerful relationship building tool to get others to be on your side of the fence, and they will fend for you in almost all situations. We all can learn from being loyal.

    .
  • 14 OCTOBER 2010
    Anushree Dhanraj
    Self-employed tutor
    India

    ...A moment of truth divulging negative experience can be instrumental in identifying the base cause for inter-department and inter-personal anxities....

    .
    Anushree Dhanraj
    Self-employed tutor
    India

    Organisations have people working in them, and people have hearts. Any value that’s close to one’s heart forms the basis of his or her behaviour and habits. The example was great. The moral of a real-life incident induced a deep rooted value for her.

    A moment of truth divulging negative experience can be instrumental in identifying the base cause for inter-department and inter-personal anxities. If addressed, and maybe cured, in a healthy manner this should bring about an environment of harmony.

    .
  • 13 OCTOBER 2010
    Egor Orlov
    Student
    SU-HSE
    Moscow Russia

    Sharing leaders’ values with others will be the most effective when these values are transpersonal, not personal. The difference is that transpersonal values dominate life itself....

    .
    Egor Orlov
    Student
    SU-HSE
    Moscow Russia

    Sharing leaders’ values with others will be the most effective when these values are transpersonal, not personal. The difference is that transpersonal values dominate life itself. It is like when the girl forgot about everything and ran to save her friend.

    .
  • 11 OCTOBER 2010
    John Farrer
    Managing Director
    POD Training
    London UK

    Great story. As a leadership trainer, I often ask participants to identify their own values, so that they are more sure of who they are and therefore more confident and assertive....

    .
    John Farrer
    Managing Director
    POD Training
    London UK

    Great story. As a leadership trainer, I often ask participants to identify their own values, so that they are more sure of who they are and therefore more confident and assertive. This is a really useful way of doing this, finding out what lies inside us by reflecting on our own moments of truth.

    .
  • 10 OCTOBER 2010
    Anuj Jindal
    Manager - Customer Service
    Manipal Hospital
    Bangalore, India

    ...the managers/leaders should also encourage their subordinates to share their ‘moments of truth’ as well. This helps in fostering a value-driven culture...

    .
    Anuj Jindal
    Manager - Customer Service
    Manipal Hospital
    Bangalore, India

    I feel in today’s organizations employees are looking for more than a salary and work environment. They seek genuine inspiration, a genuine purpose to come to work. Managers/leaders have a great responsibility on their shoulders to fulfill this need of their subordinates. Action is much louder than theoretical discussions about values. The behaviour of managers/leaders at the workplace reflects their real intent, and no one can pretend all the 365 days.

    From my observations, I have felt that subordinates demand their superiors to display their values in actions. This generates the trust, as discussed by Dr. Mike and Srikeerthi. At that moment, they graduate from being subordinates to being followers. It actually makes life so easy at the workplace because the level of understanding is huge. People are less doubtful of each other. I would also like to add here that the managers/leaders should also encourage their subordinates to share their ‘moments of truth’ as well. This helps in fostering a value-driven culture because more and more employees at different levels in the hierarchy are able to relate to each other’s and to the organisation’s values. It breaks down barriers and creates a sense of belonging. I am lucky to have experienced such a phenomenon.

    .
  • 10 OCTOBER 2010
    Jac Phillips
    Senior Manager, Private Bank
    ANZ
    Australia

    This was terrific! The power of storytelling done in an honest, compelling and meaningful way can move organisations.

    .
    Jac Phillips
    Senior Manager, Private Bank
    ANZ
    Australia

    This was terrific! The power of storytelling done in an honest, compelling and meaningful way can move organisations.

    .
  • 10 OCTOBER 2010
    Angel Gavieiro
    Head of Strategy and BD, Corp.Bkg.
    Lloyds Banking Group
    London, UK

    ...Now, the permanent question in my mind is whether wearing this honesty will be sustainable in a business world where, let’s face it, concealed intentions and covered dishonesty is quite prevailing....

    .
    Angel Gavieiro
    Head of Strategy and BD, Corp.Bkg.
    Lloyds Banking Group
    London, UK

    Exemplary story, thanks for sharing it. I empathize with this way of understanding leadership because, though with less powerful personal stories, I have shared with my teams in the past and, as importantly, acted consequently when moments of truth arrived.

    Now, the permanent question in my mind is whether wearing this honesty will be sustainable in a business world where, let’s face it (and the governance issues behind the current crisis are good proof of it), concealed intentions and covered dishonesty is quite prevailing. I saw myself arbitraged-away in some occassions while acting under this flag, while I witness other people getting away quite easily by precisely clearly renouncing to this flag and acting in purest self-interest does not matter what.

    Not advocating to adopt those people positions, but I guess remarking that as your career progresses and responsibility grows, the system does not seem to be wired in favour, and so does not make it easy at all to sustain this leadership style... I wonder whether it will reach a point of pure incompatibility...or else there is light at the end...

    ... just food for thought.

    .
  • 8 OCTOBER 2010
    Bodhisattwa Chatterjee
    Business Process Specialist
    Avaya India
    Pune, India

    ...In some cases, it can sound even boastful, like “I know you guys are facing a tough situation, but when I faced it, I did this and it was so great”...

    .
    Bodhisattwa Chatterjee
    Business Process Specialist
    Avaya India
    Pune, India

    Great story, but agree with Maksym that unless backed up by appropriate actions, such stories can have the exact opposite effects. In some cases, it can sound even boastful, like “I know you guys are facing a tough situation, but when I faced it, I did this and it was so great” stuff. But do agree that a leader does make a difference, and most learning happens through these stories, whether success stories or failures. Also, it gives a boost to do better than the leader did in similar situations, and thats what can be most rewarding, I guess.

    .
  • 8 OCTOBER 2010
    Thanh Tran Hoang
    Manager
    Tomato Trading Co
    Vietnam

    ...In my opinion, management is science, but leadership is human and emotion. A great leader is a person who understands complicated things but knows how to deliver them in simple and comprehensive ways.

    .
    Thanh Tran Hoang
    Manager
    Tomato Trading Co
    Vietnam

    The art of “revealing your moment of truth” is one idea of human behavior. Studies figured out that people prefer specific than abstract. They tend to memorize true stories rather than theories. Those things trigger our brain to absorb it faster and easier. Emotion is believed to control human behavior. In my opinion, management is science, but leadership is human and emotion. A great leader is a person who understands complicated things but knows how to deliver them in simple and comprehensive ways.

    .
  • 7 OCTOBER 2010
    Henk Jansen
    RVP Professional Services
    Infor Global Solutions
    EMEA

    ...we should not see the moment of truth as a one-trick pony, rather, as one element (maybe even a first start) helping managers to become followed leaders...

    .
    Henk Jansen
    RVP Professional Services
    Infor Global Solutions
    EMEA

    The moment of truth works, and actions do speak louder than words (also true), however we should not see the moment of truth as a one-trick pony, rather, as one element (maybe even a first start) helping managers to become followed leaders striving for something much greater.

    .
  • 7 OCTOBER 2010
    Ian Hardy
    Asset Manager (Physical Assets)
    Tata Steel (Europe)
    Scunthorpe UK

    ...It helps break down the perceptions of the “manager/leader” that might be in people’s head due to previous experiences....

    .
    Ian Hardy
    Asset Manager (Physical Assets)
    Tata Steel (Europe)
    Scunthorpe UK

    An excellent example of building emotional attachment with the team, for all the right reasons. It helps break down the perceptions of the “manager/leader” that might be in people’s head due to previous experiences. The care point it must be genuine and not just a mechanism to promote and ensure one’s own success.

    .
  • 7 OCTOBER 2010
    Radhika Shastry
    Managing Director
    RCI India
    Bangalore - India

    Tremendously powerful way to communicate that in today’s cut-throat world, values that an individual cherishes are critical for long-term success....

    .
    Radhika Shastry
    Managing Director
    RCI India
    Bangalore - India

    Tremendously powerful way to communicate that in today’s cut-throat world, values that an individual cherishes are critical for long-term success. As citizens of the world it is our responsibility to nurture and uphold values that will make this world a better place to live in. As for business, that will thrive if true values are in place!

    .
  • 6 OCTOBER 2010
    Dr. Mike Caudle
    Employee Development Coordinator
    Texas A&M University
    College Station, TX USA

    ...I have willingly and openly shared that chink in my armor to many; I am surprised at the number of people who wanted to feel that same freedom and who were encouraged to do so after my willingness to share...

    .
    Dr. Mike Caudle
    Employee Development Coordinator
    Texas A&M University
    College Station, TX USA

    After a successful military career of 22 1/2 years, I struggled to make a tough transition from a disciplined and predictable military life to one of much less discipline and predictability. It was a traumatic experience for me for quite a while, and I ultimately developed severe clinical depression for years afterward, until I finally made that huge transition, psychologically. Since that time, I have willingly and openly shared that chink in my armor to many; I am surprised at the number of people who wanted to feel that same freedom and who were encouraged to do so after my willingness to share it with them. It is critical, I believe, to be very open and honest about who we are. By so doing, we are letting our peers and reports know that we’re human just like them. It tears down barriers to effective communication and builds trust when you make yourself vulnerable. Good read, and great story.

    .
  • 6 OCTOBER 2010
    Maksym Triasunov
    Managing Director
    Xiamen Pagoda-Build Co., LTD
    China

    Touching story. But I believe it is more important to live your values and act according to them, rather than just telling stories. A leader’s actions tell much more than his words....

    .
    Maksym Triasunov
    Managing Director
    Xiamen Pagoda-Build Co., LTD
    China

    Touching story. But I believe it is more important to live your values and act according to them, rather than just telling stories. A leader’s actions tell much more than his words. If you want to promote loyalty, be loyal and encourage loyalty of your employees by praising, promoting, etcetera. Actually saving someone at a workplace when he/she needs your help might be much more powerful than telling the story of how you did it in a school. And more than this, if you tell this kind of touchy stories but then act differently (or it is interpreted by others so), then it is easy to lose credibility and simply put yourself in an embarrassing position. So, my advice is to be modest in touchy-talking but very explicit in acting :)

    .
  • 6 OCTOBER 2010
    Dr. Vaman Jagannathan
    Director
    MedAku
    Chennai, India

    ...Leadership can include an element of divinity that makes your team follow the path with absolute dedication and loyalty. These values may sound old fashioned, but can change the world of business if seen in action...

    .
    Dr. Vaman Jagannathan
    Director
    MedAku
    Chennai, India

    ‘I am Coming Back For You’ - packs power and divinity. Divinity? Yes. Leadership can include an element of divinity that makes your team follow the path with absolute dedication and loyalty. These values may sound old fashioned, but can change the world of business if seen in action (especially in a world where you can not trust your own shadow!).

    .
  • 6 OCTOBER 2010
    R Srikeerthi
    KM Assistant
    Tata Steel
    India

    ...It’s natural whenever you open up and stick to what you say, people will definitely share your value system and that will improve group dynamics.

    .
    R Srikeerthi
    KM Assistant
    Tata Steel
    India

    The story is really good. It’s really so close to hearts that it will build the best bonds among your peers that will develop mutual trust in the long run. It’s natural whenever you open up and stick to what you say, people will definitely share your value system and that will improve group dynamics.

    .
  • 5 OCTOBER 2010
    Raman Srikanth
    General Manager
    Tata Steel
    India

    A very touching story. One needs a lot of introspection and courage to share such stories in front of a full office. But, it is worth trying since the rewards are so great.

    .
    Raman Srikanth
    General Manager
    Tata Steel
    India

    A very touching story. One needs a lot of introspection and courage to share such stories in front of a full office. But, it is worth trying since the rewards are so great.

    .
  • 4 OCTOBER 2010
    Elsie Maio
    President
    SoulBranding Institute Maio & Co
    New York, NY USA

    Thank you for a compelling illustration of the double-sided glory of living our humanity at work. For the past decade we have documented the bottom-line benefits of such behaviors as Stan Slap relays in this story....

    .
    Elsie Maio
    President
    SoulBranding Institute Maio & Co
    New York, NY USA

    Thank you for a compelling illustration of the double-sided glory of living our humanity at work. For the past decade we have documented the bottom-line benefits of such behaviors as Stan Slap relays in this story. I am looking forward to reading his new book, and to the mainstreaming of human values as the explicit drivers of both organizational performance and a new capitalism.

    .
  • 4 OCTOBER 2010
    Therese Lenk
    CEO
    Meadowlark Consulting Group
    San Jose, CA USA

    ...the one story example you chose, is a touching, heart-felt, yet perfect example of true leadership. Well done. Thank you to the woman for sharing her heart wrenching story....

    .
    Therese Lenk
    CEO
    Meadowlark Consulting Group
    San Jose, CA USA

    Very advanced thinking about the purpose of leadership—thank you for putting it out there in the business world! And, the one story example you chose, is a touching, heart-felt, yet perfect example of true leadership. Well done. Thank you to the woman for sharing her heart wrenching story. I am sure your children are proud of their mother. I am glad you lived to tell it and have others learn from it. May we all learn to be more human inside and outside of work!

    .
Submit Your Comments

The user information you enter into this form will not update your site profile. To update your profile, please visit your profile page.

Subject Revealing your moment of truth

*Required

We may publish your comments online and in the print edition of McKinsey Quarterly. Those chosen, which may be edited for length and clarity, will appear along with your name and details, but not your e-mail address. We will use your e-mail address only to send you a confirmation copy of your comments and to notify you if we publish them online.

We value your feedback and will consider it carefully. Nonetheless, we receive so many comments that we cannot acknowledge all of them.

See also:
Preview

Related Audio

McKinsey’s Joanna Barsh and Johanne Lavoie discuss how to use centered leadership to guide the development of transformational leaders, as well as how centered leaders can apply their capabilities to benefit their organizations. To listen, use the audio tool in the box to the left.

Featured Package

The best leadership model: Yourself
Explore the full package for more about why the personal strengths and values we draw from our own lives can produce the best leadership traits in the workplace and beyond.

Embed E-mail