The McKinsey Quarterly

  • Recommend (86)
  • Text Size
  • Print
  • Download PDF
  • Link to This

Tapping China’s luxury-goods market

By 2015, Chinese consumers will account for more than 20 percent of the global luxury market. How is their behavior evolving?

China will account for about 20 percent, or 180 billion renminbi ($27 billion1), of global luxury sales in 2015, according to new McKinsey research. Even during the global recession in 2009, sales of luxury goods in the mainland rose by 16 percent, to about 64 billion renminbi—down from the 20 percent growth of previous years but far better than the performance of many other major luxury markets. To get a better idea of the dynamics, McKinsey surveyed more than 1,500 luxury consumers in 17 Chinese cities in spring 2010.2 Three findings stood out.

Shifting attitudes

At a time of rapidly rising incomes, widely available luxury products (and information about them), and shifting attitudes toward the display of wealth, more Chinese consumers than ever feel comfortable buying luxury goods. As a result, China’s love for them is moving down the economic ladder, creating opportunities and challenges for marketers accustomed to serving only the very rich. While wealthy consumers (with incomes above 300,000 renminbi, or about $46,000) will continue to account for a majority of luxury consumption, our research shows that the 13 million households in China’s upper middle class (incomes between 100,000 and 200,000 renminbi) offer the biggest new growth opportunity. They already account for about 12 percent of the market, and their numbers are growing rapidly: we expect to see 76 million households in this income range by 2015, accounting for 22 percent of luxury-goods purchases (Exhibit 1).

Interest in them is moving beyond handbags, jewelry, fashion, and the like. A growing number of Chinese luxury consumers are also splurging on spas and other wellness activities. Consumption is growing faster for such luxury services than for luxury goods: 20 percent of these consumers said they were spending more on experiences, only 13 percent on products.

Greater sophistication

The Chinese are increasingly exposed to luxury goods through the Internet, overseas travel, and first-hand experience. As a result, they have become more discerning.

With the surge in the number of luxury stores, fashion magazines, and Web sites and the use of social media, Chinese consumers are now familiar with nearly twice as many brands as they were in 2008. Half of the consumers we surveyed in 2010, for instance, could name more than three ready-to-wear brands, compared with only 23 percent two years before. As Chinese consumers become more familiar with luxury goods, they are becoming savvier about the relationship between quality and price. In 2010, only about half of consumers equated the most expensive products with the best ones, down from 66 percent in 2008.

Price transparency contributes to this dynamic. More than half of luxury consumers check product details and prices online, compared with 13 percent of all urban dwellers. Since two out of three luxury consumers have made at least one trip overseas, they have access to external benchmarks for comparing prices back home. In 2008, only two of five people in China realized that in the mainland, prices were at least 20 percent higher than they were in places such as Hong Kong. By 2010, 66 percent did.

Luxury-goods companies have long waged a battle against counterfeit goods in China. But there’s good news for marketers: our research shows that consumers increasingly want the real thing. The percentage of those who said they would buy fake jewelry, for example, dropped to 12 percent, from 31 percent, in 2008. Some luxury buyers told us they felt sure that their friends would spot a counterfeit. A woman who used her first salary check to reward herself with a luxury handbag said, “it would be meaningless if it was fake.” What’s more, an internationally well-known brand has become one of the most important factors in making a purchase (Exhibit 2).

New geographic markets

Rapid urbanization and growing wealth beyond China’s largest cities are creating a number of geographic markets with sizable pools of luxury-goods consumers. More small cities will become large enough to justify the presence of stores catering to them; we expect luxury sales in urban areas such as Qingdao and Wuxi, for instance, to triple over the next five years. By 2015, consumption in such cities will approach today’s levels in Hangzhou and Nanjing—now two of China’s most developed luxury-goods markets—and luxury consumption could pass 500 million renminbi in more than 60 cities, compared with 30 today. But the luxury-goods market will remain concentrated in the top 36, which will account for 74 percent of the market’s growth and 76 percent of total luxury sales by 2015.

Most of the world’s luxury-goods companies are already in China or contemplating increased investment there. They must tackle several big issues before making their next moves. First, delivering exceptional service in stores is critical; two out of three consumers are disappointed with the indifferent attitudes of salespeople. While the in-store experience is by far the most important factor driving purchasing decisions, the Internet has rapidly become the second-most-important consumer touch point for luxury categories such as fashion. Marketers will need increasingly sophisticated Web strategies; for example, they can work with social-media agencies to monitor and shape online conversations among consumers or to identify influential bloggers and help educate them about brands.

Finally, much of luxury’s allure comes from the opportunity to share in the rich cultural heritage associated with a brand. This concept is rapidly catching on with Chinese luxury consumers, and many leading brands are promoting their history and craftsmanship. But the picture isn’t totally straightforward: one-third of luxury consumers in China said they would prefer to buy products that were designed specifically for the country and incorporated Chinese imagery.

About the Authors

Yuval Atsmon is a principal in McKinsey’s Shanghai office, where Vinay Dixit leads McKinsey’s Insights China and Cathy Wu is a consultant.


The authors would like to thank Glenn Leibowitz, Lillian Li, Jia Liu, and Rachel Zheng for their contributions to the study and the development of this article.

Notes

1 At the December 2010 exchange rate.

2 The full report, Understanding China’s Growing Love for Luxury (PDF), is available on the McKinsey Insights China Web site.

Recommend (86)
  • 19 APRIL 2011
    Andy Li
    VP, Credit and Research
    Mizuho Corporate Bank
    Hong Kong, China

    ...A reasonable percentage of luxury-goods demand is driven by the “gift” factor—that’s why the ratio of luxury goods spending by males in China is the highest in the world;...

    .
    Andy Li
    VP, Credit and Research
    Mizuho Corporate Bank
    Hong Kong, China

    China’s (and Asia’s) luxury-goods market is often under-estimated owing to a few reasons:
    - The strong desire to display wealth and taste, making people to spend beyond what they are expected at a given income level.
    - A reasonable percentage of luxury-goods demand is driven by the “gift” factor—that’s why the ratio of luxury goods spending by males in China is the highest in the world.
    - The number of “wealthy” and “very wealthy” households is often understated as many millionaires (and even billionaires) are “hidden.”
    - The peer-group effect creates the “need” rather than a personal desire.

    .
  • 14 APRIL 2011
    JP Kuehlwein
    Director Corporate Strategy
    P&G
    Cincinnati, OH USA

    ...I would expect us to see more and more local luxury brands to emerge next and consumer behaviors to diversify at the same time. Exciting times ahead for everyone in the industry.

    .
    JP Kuehlwein
    Director Corporate Strategy
    P&G
    Cincinnati, OH USA

    I agree with Richard. The luxury consumer, and with it the market, will evolve. There seems to be a pattern starting with conspicuous display of wealth to signal success and status. Many jump on the bandwagon wanting to join via purchase of the more affordable accessories of these badge-brands. As big luxury brands become omnipresent, some consumers start to look for rarer, less-known labels that can identify them as a sophisticated avant-garde. In parallel, the maturing rich move from nouveau-riche bling to proven luxury values. Often delighting in their confidence to understate. At its most extreme, this intrinsic, introverted enjoyment of luxury is purely self-centered and heavily skewed towards luxury experiences like travel, spa visits, or even the (exclusive) pleasure to know that one’s shoes are printed on the inside.

    The longer a luxury market has had time to mature, the more these luxury motivations and behaviors will exist in parallel. This is the case in Europe, for example. In China, the market is still young and is just evolving beyond the obvious, aspirational luxury brand expansion. I would expect us to see more and more local luxury brands to emerge next and consumer behaviors to diversify at the same time. Exciting times ahead for everyone in the industry.

    .
  • 10 APRIL 2011
    Jun Huang
    Student
    Columbia University
    USA

    ...other than hedonistically driven purchasing decisions, to what extent is the growth of luxury–good consumption fueled by business–related needs?

    .
    Jun Huang
    Student
    Columbia University
    USA

    I would like to know more about the motivation behind the results shown in exhibit 1. The prediction seems too optimistic to me, given the economic challenges China is facing at home and abroad.

    And other than hedonistically driven purchasing decisions, to what extent is the growth of luxury–good consumption fueled by business–related needs (e.g., luxury cars, golf club memberships)?

    .
    OUR REPLY
    MKQ_response

    McKinsey's Yuval Atsmon responds:

    China has a uniquely high level of luxury–goods consumption related to business gifting. This is particularly high in some segments—most notably wine and spirits, where the local luxury white liquor “baijiu” is flourishing and rapidly increasing in price, but also in watches and other accessories. This trend is likely to continue and is linked closely to business activity. We do see, however, faster growth and significant room for additional growth coming directly from consumers buying highly desired goods for themselves.

    OUR REPLY
  • 7 APRIL 2011
    Harriet Windee
    Business Development Manager
    Hong Kong

    I note that this study omits the motivational factors driving the purchase of luxury goods—it’s not just economic prosperity....

    .
    Harriet Windee
    Business Development Manager
    Hong Kong

    I note that this study omits the motivational factors driving the purchase of luxury goods—it’s not just economic prosperity. Having lived in Asia for 12 years, one of the factors you get used to is huge prestige value in having luxury brands—every fifth hand bag you spot in HK’s Central district is LV.

    The hunger for luxury brands by the Chinese or Asian market is well acknowledged and much covered. What would be of more interest is how the luxury brands view this new consumer growth. A huge part of their success is the aspirational allure of ownership, exclusivity, and the ‘right’ kind of ambassadors for their brand. Just recall what happened to Burberry in UK after working class folk and c-list celebs hijacked the infamous Burberry check (plaid)- it became decidedly uncool and common.

    Finally, I disagree with store service being the most important factor in a purchase decision. In an excellent study by Sampson Lee, the bad in-store experience of Chinese consumers shopping in Louis Vuitton is covered in detail. However, bad service quite clearly does not deter purchase and Mr. Lee even questions whether an improved service may hinder sales as the pain points my even contribute to the desirability!

    Good on Mr. Lee for weaving the human, emotional factors into purchasing decisions (and not just the size of your wallet).

    .
    OUR REPLY
    MKQ_response

    McKinsey's Yuval Atsmon responds:

    As in many categories in China, growth is often driven by a confluence of increases in affordability, affinity, and availability. The luxury market’s spectacular growth owes to accelerated development in each of these areas. In our longer report, Understanding China’s Growing Love for Luxury, we discuss the motivation among both the wealthy consumers and those who earn less but nonetheless are willing to spend big-time on luxury brands.

    OUR REPLY
  • 6 APRIL 2011
    Simon Wong
    Principle
    Wong Audette Partners
    Toronto Canada

    ...I think the market for luxury goods with “Chinese characteristics” would have a greater potential for the long run. After all, what makes you stand out when half of people show up in a party carrying the same Chanel bag,...

    .
    Simon Wong
    Principle
    Wong Audette Partners
    Toronto Canada

    At this stage of development in the Chinese luxury goods market, we are still talking about brands’ equal “taste and refinement.” I still remember the days when men wore their suits with brands displayed on the sleeves on the streets of Shanghai.

    I think the market for luxury goods with “Chinese characteristics” would have a greater potential for the long run. After all, what makes you stand out when half of people show up in a party carrying the same Chanel bag, or whatever?

    .
  • 6 APRIL 2011
    Patrick Lohlein
    Asia Business Specialist
    Go East Consulting
    UK

    ...it is very difficult to predict how these social pressures to what is termed “conspicuous consumption” will affect the attitudes and spending habits of China’s affluent population.

    .
    Patrick Lohlein
    Asia Business Specialist
    Go East Consulting
    UK

    Indeed this trend is an Asia-wide phenomenon, and while I agree with most of the above, the analysis appears to be solely based on the data of the study, where as in practice there are certain risks that must not be discounted.

    Regarding the “shifting attitudes” in China, there is also a real danger of market distortions, as seen by Beijing’s recent luxury advertising ban. If this is an indication of the Chinese government’s determination to be seen to address social pressures against perceived high levels of inequality, then it creates substantial potential risks in both policy and market demand.

    Even if there are no more specific policy initiatives, it is very difficult to predict how these social pressures to what is termed “conspicuous consumption” will affect the attitudes and spending habits of China’s affluent population.

    .
  • 6 APRIL 2011
    Paurav Shukla
    Senior lecturer
    University of Brighton
    Brighton, UK

    I believe this result was bound to appear with the aggressive marketing tactics used by luxury firms in emerging markets. In my research, I have observed similar findings in India, Vietnam, Malaysia, and South Africa....

    .
    Paurav Shukla
    Senior lecturer
    University of Brighton
    Brighton, UK

    I believe this result was bound to appear with the aggressive marketing tactics used by luxury firms in emerging markets. In my research, I have observed similar findings in India, Vietnam, Malaysia, and South Africa.

    The interesting next question for us researchers is to think how local luxuries are going to fight back. Food for thought.

    .
  • 6 APRIL 2011
    Torsten Hoppe
    Finance Director
    Coca-Cola China
    Shanghai, PR China

    ...Staff are generally lacking deeply-rooted product knowledge or cultural appreciation of the luxury world (beyond the number on the price tag) which mostly prevents them from engaging with the consumer....

    .
    Torsten Hoppe
    Finance Director
    Coca-Cola China
    Shanghai, PR China

    From my personal experience, I can only underline the pivotal need to improve the current sub-par service level that prohibits any kind of “in-store experience.” Staff are generally lacking deeply-rooted product knowledge or cultural appreciation of the luxury world (beyond the number on the price tag) which mostly prevents them from engaging with the consumer. In combination with the 30% mark-up of Mainland prices versus Hong Kong/Macau, it is hardly surprising to observe a steep increase of those handbag bulk purchase weekend trips to the SAR. It will be interesting to see which of the luxury retailers can crack the code and develop the kind of shopping experience that will be required to retain consumers, drive repeat purchase and sustain growth.

    .
  • 5 APRIL 2011
    James Chan
    President
    AMM
    Philadelphia, PA USA

    ...Of special value is the affirmation that many Chinese salespeople are not adequately trained to sell to people with taste and refinement....

    .
    James Chan
    President
    AMM
    Philadelphia, PA USA

    The Chinese are no different from other peoples. They’ll learn to tell price from value in due course. The value of this article is that it affirms what should be happening.

    Of special value is the affirmation that many Chinese salespeople are not adequately trained to sell to people with taste and refinement. More on this issue can be found in the book I Want That by Thomas Hine, an American writer and critic on design, shopping, culture, and architecture.

    .
  • 5 APRIL 2011
    Irene Zhang
    Regional Purchasing Manager
    ABF
    Shanghai, China

    ...I am very glad to read your article on the optimistic future in China by 2015, but I am wondering how you are able to make this kind of forecast?...

    .
    Irene Zhang
    Regional Purchasing Manager
    ABF
    Shanghai, China

    I went to Hong Kong end of February and early March. Definitely some shops there and I noted the price was much cheaper than in inland China. For example, on cosmetics, 30 to 35 percent lower; watches and handbags differ from brand to brand or some with just the foreign exchange difference.
    I am very glad to read your article on the optimistic future in China by 2015, but I am wondering how you are able to make this kind of forecast? What are the reasons behind consumers’ salary increase, government’s tariff decrease, or some other factor? The want is not enough, but it takes income and price for the consumer to make a buying decision.

    .
  • 5 APRIL 2011
    Pramod Agarwal
    Vice President Finance Asia
    Procter & Gamble
    Singapore

    ...We expect similar trends in other markets like India as income levels grow.

    .
    Pramod Agarwal
    Vice President Finance Asia
    Procter & Gamble
    Singapore

    We are seeing similar a pattern—the super premium segment of the consumer goods industry is growing the fastest. Consumers are increasingly becoming more savvy shoppers and willing to pay extra bucks for the right product. We expect similar trends in other markets like India as income levels grow.

    .
  • 5 APRIL 2011
    Clara Muriel
    Shanghai, China

    ...I wonder...whether we are about to witness a more hostile environment for luxury brands in the future...

    .
    Clara Muriel
    Shanghai, China

    We all see a bright future in China’s luxury goods market. Having said that, last month we read the news that Beijing has banned outdoor advertising that promotes hedonistic or high-end lifestyles, that is luxury products. Most articles read it as a response to Premier Wen Jiabao’s words earlier that month stating that “resolving unfair income distribution” would be a major objective under a 2011-2015 state economic plan.
    I wonder if it is just the beginning of something bigger, and whether we are about to witness a more hostile environment for luxury brands in the future.
    Probably there is still a bright future ahead, but I’m sure luxury good companies are not seeing this as good news.

    .
    OUR REPLY
    MKQ_response

    McKinsey's Yuval Atsmon responds:

    It’s interesting to note that both the consumers and the Chinese government seem to increasingly prefer subtle luxury consumption. In the last National People’s Congress in March, senior government officials provided their own forecast for the luxury market and promised to consider policy changes that would encourage greater domestic consumption. This was part of a much broader promise to help shift GDP structure and increase share of domestic consumption from the mid-thirties (today, only 35 percent of GDP is consumption–related, half as much as it is in the United States) to the mid-forties. Yet, the ban on advertising with the word “luxury” in Beijing and a slew of other statements discouraged conspicuous luxury consumption.

    We believe the implication for the luxury market is not how much will be bought, but rather what will the consumer buy and what will drive their purchases. As in the rest of the world, we expect to see “responsible consumption” in the future.

    OUR REPLY
  • 4 APRIL 2011
    Michael Stanat
    Author of China's Generation Y and Manager
    SIS International Research
    New York, NY US

    ...In my research of China’s Generation Y, I noticed the aspirational aspect of marketing growing....

    .
    Michael Stanat
    Author of China's Generation Y and Manager
    SIS International Research
    New York, NY US

    Very interesting findings. In my research of China’s Generation Y, I noticed the aspirational aspect of marketing growing. Young people in China are searching for identity, and consumerism (even conspicuous consumption) is one way that some in China are increasingly displaying status in society.

    .
  • 4 APRIL 2011
    Richard Seireeni
    President
    The Brand Architect Group
    Los Angeles, CA USA

    My Tokyo partner and I have been conducting business in Asia for over 30 years. We see China moving through the same consumer desires as Japan experienced beginning in the 1980s....

    .
    Richard Seireeni
    President
    The Brand Architect Group
    Los Angeles, CA USA

    My Tokyo partner and I have been conducting business in Asia for over 30 years. We see China moving through the same consumer desires as Japan experienced beginning in the 1980s. Luxury goods in China are currently defined as the obvious, well-known and well-marketed brands: Chanel, Gucci, BMW, etcetera. Innovative and/or cutting-edge luxury brands still struggle in the Chinese market. But not so in Japan where the definition of luxury has matured to include smaller, less well-known luxury makers that express a “coolness” factor often missing in the big brands.

    .
Submit Your Comments

The user information you enter into this form will not update your site profile. To update your profile, please visit your profile page.

Subject Tapping China’s luxury-goods market

*Required

We may publish your comments online and in the print edition of McKinsey Quarterly. Those chosen, which may be edited for length and clarity, will appear along with your name and details, but not your e-mail address. We will use your e-mail address only to send you a confirmation copy of your comments and to notify you if we publish them online.

We value your feedback and will consider it carefully. Nonetheless, we receive so many comments that we cannot acknowledge all of them.

See also:
Preview

Embed E-mail