The McKinsey Quarterly

  • Recommend (79)
  • Text Size
  • Print
  • Download PDF
  • Link to This

How new Internet standards will finally deliver a mobile revolution

As the Web experience evolves, smartphones may soon live up to their name, and every business’s mobile strategy will grow in importance.

An arcane-sounding change with potentially significant implications for consumers and businesses is under way on the Web: the shift to a new generation of HTML,1 the programming standard that underpins the Internet. Senior executives, regardless of industry, should take note; like the exponential growth of device-specific applications, this evolution of HTML will further boost the power of mobile devices, accelerating changes in the way people consume content and the potential use of smartphones and tablets as both a marketing platform and a productivity tool.

The next generation of the Internet standard essentially will allow programs to run through a Web browser rather than a specific operating system. That means consumers will be able to access the same programs and cloud-based content from any device—personal computer, laptop, smartphone, or tablet—because the browser is the common platform. This ability to work seamlessly anytime, anywhere, on any device could change consumer behavior and shift the balance of power in the mobile-telecommunications, media, and technology industries. It will create opportunities and present challenges. This article seeks to provide a primer on these changes for senior executives, who may feel the effects of the move toward “Web-centricity” much sooner than they think.

Web-centricity

In some ways, the evolution of mobile technology resembles the battle among PC makers in the 1980s. While we today take it for granted that Microsoft’s Windows operating system underpins hardware from countless manufacturers, it wasn’t always that way. Remember the operating systems that powered the Commodore 64, the biggest-selling PC of all time, or the Apple II? Before the emergence of Microsoft’s DOS and then Windows, PC users faced a tough decision about which technology to adopt, because that determined the games and utilities they could use, as well as the general usefulness of their computers. The same occurs today with mobile devices. Users must weigh the hardware and software merits and commit themselves to a technology, whether it’s a device from manufacturers such as Apple or Research in Motion, the ever-increasing array of tablets and smartphones running Google’s Android operating system, or, soon, offerings from Nokia running on Microsoft’s Windows Phone 7 operating system.

The next generation of HTML, known as HTML5, may narrow these differences between mobile devices. HTML5, the most significant evolution yet in Web standards, is designed to allow programs to run through a Web browser, complete with video and other multimedia content that today require plug-in software and other work-arounds. In theory, this will make the browser a universal computing platform: without leaving it, users could do everything from editing documents to accessing social networks, watching movies, playing games, or listening to music. Not only would any device with a Web browser have these capabilities, but consumers would also have access to all content stored remotely “in the cloud,” independent of locations and devices.

That’s the first reason Web-centricity holds particular promise for mobile devices. The second is that it helps overcome the relatively weak processing power of smartphones and tablets compared with PCs and laptops. It’s partly this lack of horsepower that has fuelled the explosive growth in applications (or “apps”) to optimize the performance of specific devices: the average smartphone user now spends more than 11 hours a month using apps, more time than either Web browsing or talking, according to a March 2011 study by research firm Zokem. HTML5 has the potential to improve the mobile experience—its specifications enable browsers to locally store 1,000 times more data than they currently do, so users can work when offline—writing e-mails, for example—and their devices will automatically update when a network becomes available. What’s more, programs and applications run faster because complex processing tasks are handled by network servers, although mobile-network capacity must go on growing to deal with heavier data demands.

 

Of course, not all programs are suited to running through browsers, nor is HTML5 the first would-be universal platform to emerge: Sun Microsystems (purchased by Oracle in 2010) promised that with its Java language, programmers could “write once, run anywhere.” Things haven’t worked out that way. And there’s never a guarantee that one kind of standard will prevail (see sidebar, “Winning the Web standards battle”). The rate at which developers are writing apps and consumers buying them is dizzying, and ingrained behavior can be hard to change. Web-centricity may raise security fears among users because programs are no longer installed on specific devices and because data are stored remotely. And there could be fragmentation issues with both the standard and the browsers—after all, existing ones, such as Google’s Chrome, Microsoft’s Internet Explorer, and Mozilla’s Firefox, don’t all treat the current standard, HTML4, the same way.2

Despite these possible headwinds, the number of HTML5 Web sites is increasing by the day. Hardware manufacturers are lining up behind HTML5, and the development community is undertaking efforts to safeguard data in the cloud at a very fast pace. We therefore estimate that more than 50 percent of all mobile applications will switch to HTML5 within three to five years—and the rate of transition could be considerably higher and faster. No matter how quickly the shift occurs, it will affect both consumers and businesses significantly.

Consumer impact

Consider a simple task many consumers currently use mobile devices for: reading news headlines. Today, that requires accessing a specific Web site—often a sluggish exercise in frustration—or separately installing an application on every device used and, for those that charge a fee, paying each time. With Web-centricity, a single application can theoretically be accessed from any device through a browser—pay once and you’re done. And because all content is stored in the cloud, billing information and preferences can be seamlessly shared and accessed, and all devices remain in sync. A consumer can start reading an article on a tablet and then switch to a laptop, picking up where she left off. In a more advanced example, she could start an instant-messaging or video-chat conversation on her desktop computer and continue it on her smartphone. The bottom line for consumers: Web-centricity represents a major step toward genuinely “smart” devices that offer the same simple, relevant, and personalized experience everywhere.

Industry impact

These changes to consumer behavior may affect the economics of industries ranging from telecommunications and media to technology and even advertising. As Web stores selling applications that can be used across devices proliferate, for example, cutthroat competition may leave ad agencies reminiscing wistfully about the days when they could claim up to 40 percent of every dollar of mobile-advertising revenue. Consider, briefly, the implications for the following players in a world where content is everywhere and the relative importance of operating systems and Web browsers for creating and distributing programs and applications is shifting.

Software developers. Application developers currently pay a fee of up to 30 percent to device makers, telecommunications operators, or operating-system developers whenever an application is sold to a consumer. In a Web-centric world, developers can avoid these intermediaries: not only can the same application be sold across all devices but anyone can set up a Web store and sell directly to users. Google, for instance, is already charging application developers a distribution fee of about 5 percent through its Chrome Web store.3 In addition, the emergence of an open platform will probably motivate bigger enterprise software companies to introduce—and quickly—mobile-based programs for managing customer relationships, marketing, and supply chains.

Telecom operators. Web-centricity may be a double-edged sword for telecom players. On the one hand, it will spur demand for mobile-Internet services, create opportunities for operators as consumers seek applications that work across multiple devices, and loosen the grip of native app stores. On the other hand, there’s no guarantee that operators can make money with new apps, the likely surge in data traffic will require significant investments in network infrastructure, and operators may face increased competition from companies offering Web-based mobile-voice and -video services.

Content providers. Web-centricity should provide revenue and savings opportunities for content providers. On the revenue side, the ease with which consumers can access Web-centric content on the go should stimulate their interest in more relevant, timely material. Moreover, the seamlessness with which consumers can access HTML5 content across devices could create more opportunities for providers, such as television and movie studios, to offer consumers programming directly or to work through aggregators such as Apple’s iTunes. Finally, advertising could support additional mobile content. Fragmented mobile platforms today make it hard for online publishers to manage ad inventories across a broad range of users. Advanced features such as consumer targeting and measurement may migrate to the mobile-Web environment. Of course, this development will no doubt attract entrants and intensify competition, making the new environment as challenging as it is dynamic.

Savings, a secondary benefit, come from avoiding the cost of converting an application from one platform to another (today, typically around 50 percent of the original development cost). Newspapers and magazines, for example, should be able to create content once and deliver it seamlessly across multiple devices, lowering production costs and increasing reach.

Device makers. Web-centricity will probably make consumers more “device agnostic,” and that will in turn reduce the ability of players to control an ecosystem of developers and could accelerate the commoditization of mobile devices. The shift does, however, create opportunities. Manufacturers will be able to better and more easily integrate software and hardware experiences within and across devices. They can try to develop compelling cross-device applications and speed up the push to make synchronizing and storing data across devices easier. Finally, they have some control (along with operators) in choosing the default set of Web-centric services and applications embedded in devices.

What it means for senior executives

Consumer uses propel many innovations associated with Web-centricity. Yet it could ultimately provide a range of benefits for companies as information technology moves to Web-centric platforms and away from the current hard-wired infrastructure and applications. These are enterprise-level issues, and any CEO who isn’t confident that the organization is grappling with them should start pushing the senior team to understand their importance.

The CMO

The emergence of the “m-dot revolution”4—the increasingly strong tendency of consumers to use mobile devices to access company and product information—will have its greatest impact on chief marketing officers. Many companies are already experimenting with innovative smartphone applications; Volkswagen, for instance, has released a popular racing game for the iPhone. Companies will be able to continue taking advantage of the enhanced power of mobile Web browsers to create compelling experiences directly for users. In addition, CMOs will need to push their teams to develop compelling mobile-advertising strategies that go well beyond merely inserting ads into applications, as many do today. HTML5 should create opportunities to use video advertising more often, for example, and the development of robust mobile capabilities may spur the evolution of marketing tactics such as the monitoring of shopping activity to deliver real-time, location-specific coupons.

The CIO

Web-centricity puts additional pressure on organizations to invest in corporate cloud infrastructure. Chief information officers should, for example, prepare for the day when consumers, employees, and suppliers all communicate and interact through the use of mobile devices that run Web applications. This phenomenon will not only extend the reach of the enterprise but also place a premium on analytics and possibly improve the competitiveness of companies that can exploit the new information and interactions a Web-centric environment provides.

CIOs will have to decide whether costs can be cut and productivity increased by introducing rich applications both horizontally, across industries (for example, enterprise customer-relationship-management systems such as Salesforce.com), and vertically, within industries (say, mobile electronic medical records in health care or smartphone-based claims processing in insurance). Web-centricity also promises smaller productivity improvements, such as allowing users to store content locally for later uploading. Employees will therefore be able to work without being connected to the Internet—for instance, when they’re on airplanes.

The CEO

From the perspective of the chief executive officer, Web-centricity should be part of a broader imperative to elevate the importance of mobile marketing in corporate strategy. CEOs will need a response when, as must inevitably happen, they are asked how their companies are dealing with the m-dot revolution, which introduces a mobile element into everything from commerce to advertising to public relations. What’s needed is not just the coordination of mobile initiatives from functional offices, however. CEOs must take a big-picture approach to the collective implications of Web-centricity, the way it redefines a company’s interactions with employees and customers, and the challenges and opportunities it presents.

Of course, Web-centricity will require spending money to make money. Organizations will have to make IT investments, particularly for cloud-based computing and mobile platforms. Employees, especially in sales and operations, will need training in the art and science of mobility if companies are to maximize cost savings and productivity improvements. Yet Web-centricity also promises to make the mobile-Internet experience more open, complex, and dynamic. It may change the way consumers and enterprises behave. Even if companies don’t understand the technical aspects of this transition, they must master the technology’s potential and possible ramifications.

About the Authors

Bengi Korkmaz is an associate principal in McKinsey’s Istanbul office; Richard Lee is a principal in the Seoul office, where Ickjin Park is an associate principal.


The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions of Paul Choo, Michael Chui, Jinwook Kim, and Johnson Sikes to the development of this article.

Notes

1 Hypertext markup language.

2 Various plug-in programs written for HTML4, such as those that run audio or video files, often require multiple versions customized to specific browsers. As the complexity of Web programs accelerates, those mismatches are increasing. To read more about how HTML5 may help the Web keep up with the pace of change, see Bobbie Johnson, “The Web is reborn,” Technology Review, November/December 2010, Volume 113, Number 6, pp. 46–53.

3 See http://code.google.com/chrome/webstore/docs/index.html#builtin.

4 “M-dot” refers to the URL of a Web site that is optimized for mobile phones. Many of these sites include an “m.” at the beginning of the URL, such as “m.usatoday.com” or “m.facebook.com.”

Recommend (79)
  • 8 MAY 2011
    Tom Hagan
    CEO
    Actioneer, Inc.
    Boston, MA USA

    ...It took many years for Java to achieve the ubiquity it now enjoys. Many of us are hopeful that the journey will be quicker for HTML5.

    .
    Tom Hagan
    CEO
    Actioneer, Inc.
    Boston, MA USA

    An excellent piece. A link will be sent to all our directors.

    The mention of Java is instructive. “Write once, run anywhere” became “write once, debug everywhere.” It took many years for Java to achieve the ubiquity it now enjoys. Many of us are hopeful that the journey will be quicker for HTML5.

    .
  • 26 APRIL 2011
    Roderick Eeninkwinkel
    Consultant
    ANWB
    The Hague, Netherlands

    ...Another barrier to Web-centricity is the fact that each device (smartphone, tablet, PC, laptop) has a unique user experience and hence a specific function....

    .
    Roderick Eeninkwinkel
    Consultant
    ANWB
    The Hague, Netherlands

    Is the mobile revolution halfway here? Yes. Are cloud-based services the next big thing? For sure. However, this doesn’t mean that the browser will become the universal computing platform. As the sidebar tells us, the theoretical better platform doesn’t always win. In the end, it all depends on which platform consumers are going to adopt (whether or not helped with some clever marketing campaign). The current winner is Apple, with its App Store.

    Undisputably, Apple won’t give up its highly profitable closed ecosystem. Google, Nokia, RIM, Microsoft and others have launched similar initiatives. This indicates that both device-specific applications as well as HTML5 ‘applications’ probably will continue to coexist next to each other.

    Another barrier to Web-centricity is the fact that each device (smartphone, tablet, PC, laptop) has a unique user experience and hence a specific function. Playing games or editing text just isn’t the same on a smartphone as it is on a tablet or computer.

    In theory Web-centricity is a beautiful model, but the reality will turn out to be less perfect.

    .
  • 25 APRIL 2011
    Chris Tompkins
    Communications
    Wells
    San Francisco, USA

    ...Now mobile sites can be 99 percent app-like, but developers themselves would prefer their work behind a paywall.

    .
    Chris Tompkins
    Communications
    Wells
    San Francisco, USA

    It’s interesting that Apple initially launched with the Web apps models and users cried foul. Now users cry that Apple is cornering the market with native apps.

    I don’t get it: you can make wonderful Web apps using relatively simple HTML5, but no one seems to want to do it. The initial WAP movement failed due to lack of adoption because of technical limitations. Now mobile sites can be 99 percent app-like, but developers themselves would prefer their work behind a paywall.

    .
  • 22 APRIL 2011
    Charles Miller
    Director, Digital Care
    DIRECTV
    Los Angeles, CA USA

    There is a third and very important C-level impacted by this change that deserves to added to the discussion—the role of COO....

    .
    Charles Miller
    Director, Digital Care
    DIRECTV
    Los Angeles, CA USA

    There is a third and very important C-level impacted by this change that deserves to added to the discussion—the role of COO. There are cost and support implications that need to be considered and addressed.

    Mobile users overlap social media users — these customers value smartphone-based support, from dynamic FAQs, communities, and text-based escalation to a live agent (through chat or SMS messaging). A phone call is a last resort and the temperature of these customers that prefer robust self-service options will be high due to the time and inconvenience of waiting on hold.

    While this has IT-tool-infrastructure implications, one should not overlook the human resources, skills, and knowledge required to make these tools and mobile support successful.

    .
  • 21 APRIL 2011
    Ruud van Winden
    MD
    Premium Parking
    Beijing, China

    ...Concentrating money and effort on a customer's brand experience based on HTML5 will hopefully bring a revolution that goes way beyond a visit to “the company website.”

    .
    Ruud van Winden
    MD
    Premium Parking
    Beijing, China

    This line of thought is very interesting, especially the position of apps as it is now. Many apps are brilliant but overall, there are just too many. There are quite a few apps out there produced by companies that are not as succesful as they would have hoped (read: waste of money). Concentrating money and effort on a customer's brand experience based on HTML5 will hopefully bring a revolution that goes way beyond a visit to “the company website.”

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Sathiyanarayanan Rangarajan
    Senior Manager
    Oracle India
    India

    The more important aspect of the mobile revolution is the availability of enterprise applications on mobile platforms....

    .
    Sathiyanarayanan Rangarajan
    Senior Manager
    Oracle India
    India

    The more important aspect of the mobile revolution is the availability of enterprise applications on mobile platforms. That will change the way executives work and respond to the market situation. For example, the HRML5-based application may deliver business analytics in a mobile format and executives may be able to take and execute strategic and operating decisions.

    Another important area where mobile internet will have lasting impact is in learning and knowledge dissemination. Currently, mobile learning has limited application because of connectivity speed as well as storage capacity of the mobile device. With the advent of cloud and an appropriate Web browser (HTML5), even low-end devices will be e-enabled to impart learning.

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Satyabroto Banerji
    Technology Coordinator
    Safety Brigade
    Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

    Reliable connectivity, vernacular scripts, and spam marketing, are serious stumbling blocks in India....

    .
    Satyabroto Banerji
    Technology Coordinator
    Safety Brigade
    Mumbai, Maharashtra, India

    Reliable connectivity, vernacular scripts, and spam marketing are serious stumbling blocks in India. Vested interests sabotage effective changes to substitute traditional communication channels with smartphones. Price differentials between 2G and 3G subscriptions require that we review the cost-effectiveness assumptions that were probably in aim earlier, especially since it is not easy to ensure that business aids are not used for entertainment and other personal fancies.

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Sean Nugent
    Account Director
    LINE Communications
    London UK

    It’s also worth considering the effect this will have on the HR function...

    .
    Sean Nugent
    Account Director
    LINE Communications
    London UK

    It’s also worth considering the effect this will have on the HR function, for example, in talent management and recruitment, and particularly the use of mobile technology in learning and development. Mobile is fast becoming the main channel where learning, both formal and informal, is taking place.

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Vivekanand Heble
    CIO
    AFL Pvt Ltd
    Mumbai, Mahrashtra, India

    How is a statement like, “...because the browser is the common platform...” justifiable? The browser is merely the user interface. The data resides in servers, not in browsers....

    .
    Vivekanand Heble
    CIO
    AFL Pvt Ltd
    Mumbai, Mahrashtra, India

    How is a statement like, “...because the browser is the common platform...” justifiable? The browser is merely the user interface. The data resides in servers, not in browsers. In many cases (like Windows CE 5.0) the browser is the weak link in the chain. Could I have a clarification please?

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Jeannette Marshall
    Blogger
    optioneerJM
    Calgary, Alberta, Canada

    ...Just as we’re starting to figure out how social media is changing communications, it appears that m-dot will take what it has learned from Facebook and Twitter to compound the technology on mobile fronts.

    .
    Jeannette Marshall
    Blogger
    optioneerJM
    Calgary, Alberta, Canada

    This was exceptionally interesting to me, as I was in a Twitter chat the other day where we were brainstorming on technologies that were impacting sales. I’d said that I thought mobile was going to be the next wave. Possibly not earth shattering, however, I hadn’t heard the term the “m-dot revolution” until now.

    Just as we’re starting to figure out how social media is changing communications, it appears that m-dot will take what it has learned from Facebook and Twitter to compound the technology on mobile fronts.

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Nguyen Tin Buu Chau
    Senior Associate
    ITEl Heptagone Consulting
    St-Lambert, Que, Canada

    From a business perspective, surviving through a Web-centricity world will likely push the convergence to its next step...

    .
    Nguyen Tin Buu Chau
    Senior Associate
    ITEl Heptagone Consulting
    St-Lambert, Que, Canada

    From a business perspective, surviving through a Web-centricity world will likely push the convergence to its next step, characterized by the need to amalgamate apps, telecom operators, content providers, and device makers around one collaborative table. Whether anyone out of the above will emerge as the leading player within a business structure, that remains to be decided, although a secondary issue.

    .
  • 20 APRIL 2011
    Marcelo AR
    VP
    AGR
    Brazil

    I totally agree that we are about to see a revolution on Web apps, but for line-of-business productivity applications, I believe Microsoft Silverlight will play a bigger role than html5.

    .
    Marcelo AR
    VP
    AGR
    Brazil

    I totally agree that we are about to see a revolution on Web apps, but for line-of-business productivity applications, I believe Microsoft Silverlight will play a bigger role than html5.

    .
  • 19 APRIL 2011
    Michael Locke
    Managing Partner
    LOCKE pty ltd
    Sydney, Australia

    ...David, in response to your point, I agree that if Apple was the only player it would be all about monetising the innovations and opportunities. But I believe the growth of Android and the significant adoption of open-source development...

    .
    Michael Locke
    Managing Partner
    LOCKE pty ltd
    Sydney, Australia

    Nice piece, perfectly supports a number of discussions I’ve had of late with various clients currently ‘looking over the edge’ and wondering.

    David, in response to your point, I agree that if Apple was the only player it would be all about monetising the innovations and opportunities. But I believe the growth of Android and the significant adoption of open-source development around the world has let the jeanie out of the bottle. Here’s hoping anyway, I thinking keeping it clean and safe will be the biggest issue.

    .
  • 19 APRIL 2011
    Ken Manning
    MD
    Radiant Interactive
    San Francisco, CA USA

    ...The really interesting stuff (touched on above) isn’t just in the cloud; it’s in the cloud interacting with things that are unique to mobile: geo, real-time social, mRFID, AR, etcetera.

    .
    Ken Manning
    MD
    Radiant Interactive
    San Francisco, CA USA

    I had to check the date of this article after reading the first few lines. Did I stumble on a piece from 2008? I was reminded of that line from William Gibson: “The future is already here, it’s just not widely distributed.” Actually, the future started four years ago. (The world of the carrier—platform—rule has been over since then.) The age of mobile TCP/IP began with the iPhone—though not the same as an HTML5 standard we’re talking about here, it’s a web standard nevertheless. The really interesting stuff (touched on above) isn’t just in the cloud; it’s in the cloud interacting with things that are unique to mobile: geo, real-time social, mRFID, AR, etcetera.

    .
  • 19 APRIL 2011
    Venkat Mahalingam
    Consultant
    SAP Americas Inc
    Newtown Square, PA USA

    ...Additionally, it would be good to see some comments on the following: 1. Implications and changes to security...

    .
    Venkat Mahalingam
    Consultant
    SAP Americas Inc
    Newtown Square, PA USA

    Very interesting article. Additionally, it would be good to see some comments on the following:

    1. Implications and changes to security - CSO
    2. Changes to workforce in organizations
    3. Integration between cloud architecture and smart clients

    .
  • 19 APRIL 2011
    David Corfan
    Teaching Fellow
    University of Bedfordshire
    UK

    ...I was optimistic for a Web-based mobile world ten years ago, but am less confident it will ever happen now.

    .
    David Corfan
    Teaching Fellow
    University of Bedfordshire
    UK

    This is written as if it’s a new idea, but it’s exactly what WAP was all about, and it didn’t succeed both for technology and vested interest reasons of the hardware suppliers and mobile operators. HTML5 promises much, but I fear the politics of the mobile industry and the powerhouses such as Apple, RIM (perhaps mainly Apple), plus the mobile operators will try to find ways to promote their own vested interests in order to get as much of the value chain as possible. I was optimistic for a Web-based mobile world ten years ago, but am less confident it will ever happen now.

    .
  • 19 APRIL 2011
    Tana Heminsley
    CEO and Founder
    Authentic Leadership Global, Inc.
    Vancouver, B.C. Canada

    ...It raises lots of questions about how we (socially conscious business owners) are opening to the possibility of technology as a support for our offerings.

    .
    Tana Heminsley
    CEO and Founder
    Authentic Leadership Global, Inc.
    Vancouver, B.C. Canada

    What a great article—I’ve shared it using Twitter and to various groups on LinkedIn. It raises lots of questions about how we (socially conscious business owners) are opening to the possibility of technology as a support for our offerings.

    .
Submit Your Comments

The user information you enter into this form will not update your site profile. To update your profile, please visit your profile page.

Subject How new Internet standards will finally deliver a mobile revolution

*Required

We may publish your comments online and in the print edition of McKinsey Quarterly. Those chosen, which may be edited for length and clarity, will appear along with your name and details, but not your e-mail address. We will use your e-mail address only to send you a confirmation copy of your comments and to notify you if we publish them online.

We value your feedback and will consider it carefully. Nonetheless, we receive so many comments that we cannot acknowledge all of them.

See also:
Preview

Embed E-mail